Davis Schuler& AssociatesCDFA® Practice
Book
For Attorneys

Financial expert resources for family-law attorneys

Expert reports, Rule 26 disclosures, financial expert testimony, separate property tracing, business valuation, income analysis, support analysis, financial rebuttal, methodology, document requests, discovery, and trial preparation — organized for the attorney's case workflow.

Business Owner Divorce
Business Owner Divorce

Can my spouse force me to sell my business in a divorce?

In most cases, no. Utah courts rarely order a closely-held business sold because doing so destroys the operating spouse's livelihood and often reduces the sale price. Instead, the court typically awards the business to the operating spouse and orders an offsetting buyout or transfer of other marital assets to the non-operating spouse. However, in limited circumstances, such as when both spouses are co-owners and cannot work together, a sale may be ordered.

Business Owner Divorce

How is a closely-held business divided in a Utah divorce?

In Utah, a closely-held business is treated as property to the extent it was acquired or grew in value during the marriage. The court determines the business's fair market value, identifies the marital versus separate portions, and divides the marital equity. The business itself is rarely sold. Instead, the operating spouse typically retains the business and buys out the other spouse's share using offsetting assets, a structured payment, or a transfer of other marital property.

Separate Property Tracing
Separate Property Tracing

Can commingled property still be traced?

Yes, commingled property can often still be traced - commingling does not automatically destroy a separate property claim. In Utah, a spouse who has commingled separate funds with marital funds can still recover the separate portion if they can prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that the separate funds are still identifiable. The difficulty depends on the degree of commingling, the availability of records, and the tracing method used. Direct tracing is easiest; pro rata or transaction-by-transaction tracing may be needed for heavily commingled accounts.

Separate Property Tracing

How do you trace an inheritance in divorce?

Tracing an inheritance in a divorce means following the inherited funds from the moment they were received through every account and transaction to prove they remain separate property. The process starts with documentation of the inheritance (will, trust distribution, or executor letter), then follows the money through bank and brokerage statements to its current location. If the inheritance was deposited into a joint account, used to buy a shared asset, or commingled with marital funds, the tracing becomes more complex - but it may still be possible with careful forensic analysis.

Separate Property Tracing

What is separate property tracing?

Separate property tracing is the process of identifying and following a non-marital asset - such as premarital savings, an inheritance, or a gift - through bank, brokerage, and investment accounts to prove that it has not been converted into marital property. In a Utah divorce, separate property is generally not divided, but the burden is on the spouse claiming the asset to prove it remains separate. When separate funds are deposited into joint accounts or used to buy shared assets, tracing becomes essential to preserve the separate property claim.

Self-Employed Income
Self-Employed Income

How is S corporation income analyzed for alimony?

S corporation income for alimony is analyzed by looking beyond the salary on the W-2 to include K-1 distributions, retained earnings, and personal expenses paid by the business. An S corp owner can set their own salary - often artificially low - and take the rest as distributions, which are not subject to payroll tax. A financial analyst normalizes the income by adding back personal expenses, nonrecurring costs, and excess compensation, then compares the total to the lifestyle the couple lived. The goal is to find the actual cash available for support.

Self-Employed Income

How are business-paid personal expenses treated in divorce?

Business-paid personal expenses are treated as additional income to the business owner in a divorce. When a business pays for the owner's personal auto, travel, meals, insurance, or family-member salaries, those costs are not true business expenses - they are compensation in disguise. A financial analyst identifies these expenses in the general ledger and adds them back to the owner's income for support purposes. This normalization can significantly increase the income available for alimony and child support, sometimes doubling the reported figure.

Self-Employed Income

How is income determined for a self-employed spouse in divorce?

A self-employed spouse's income for divorce purposes is rarely the number on their tax return. True income includes salary, K-1 distributions, shareholder distributions, retained earnings, and personal expenses paid through the business. A financial analyst normalizes the income by adding back non-recurring expenses, personal expenses, and excess compensation, then compares the business's cash flow to the lifestyle the couple actually lived. The goal is to find the income available for support, not just the taxable income reported to the IRS.

Alimony and Support
Alimony and Support

How is income analyzed for alimony?

Income for alimony in a Utah divorce is analyzed by looking at the actual income available to each spouse for support, not just the number on a tax return. For employed spouses, this means reviewing W-2s, pay stubs, and benefits. For self-employed spouses, it means normalizing business income by adding back personal expenses, nonrecurring costs, and excess compensation. The analysis also considers variable income (bonuses, commissions), investment distributions, and the historical standard of living to determine what income is actually available for support.

Business Valuation
Business Valuation

What is the difference between personal goodwill and enterprise goodwill?

Personal goodwill is the value of a business tied to the individual owner's skills, reputation, and personal relationships - value that would not transfer to a buyer. Enterprise goodwill is the value that exists independently of the owner and can be transferred to a new owner - things like brand, systems, customer lists, and location. In a Utah divorce, this distinction matters because personal goodwill may be treated as the owner's separate property, while enterprise goodwill is generally marital. The allocation can significantly change what portion of the business value is divided.

Business Valuation

What is normalized EBITDA in a divorce business valuation?

Normalized EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization) is the business's true earning power after removing owner perks, personal expenses, nonrecurring costs, and excess compensation. In a divorce business valuation, normalization is essential because owners often run personal expenses through the business, pay family members above-market rates, and claim one-time deductions that don't reflect ongoing operations. Normalized EBITDA reveals what the business actually earns - not what the owner chose to report - and is the foundation for determining fair market value.

Business Valuation

How is a business valued during a Utah divorce?

A business is valued in a Utah divorce by determining its fair market value - the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, both with full knowledge of the facts. A Certified Valuation Analyst (CVA) or business valuation professional typically uses three approaches: the income approach (based on earning power), the market approach (based on comparable sales), and the asset approach (based on net assets). The valuation also normalizes the financial statements by removing owner perks, excess compensation, and nonrecurring expenses to reveal the business's true earning power.

Taxes and Divorce
Taxes and Divorce

What tax issues should be considered before accepting a divorce settlement?

Before accepting a divorce settlement, you should consider the after-tax value of every asset, not just the sticker price. Key tax issues include: the tax basis and potential capital gains on assets you receive, whether retirement accounts are pre-tax or Roth, the tax consequences of selling a marital home, whether alimony is taxable (for divorces finalized before 2019) or tax-free (after 2018), and the impact of transferring appreciated assets. Two assets with the same dollar value can have very different after-tax values, making a 50/50 split unequal in practice.

Taxes and Divorce

Why can two assets with the same dollar value have different after-tax values?

Two assets with the same dollar value can have different after-tax values because of differences in tax basis, tax treatment, and selling costs. A $100,000 brokerage account with a low cost basis will trigger capital gains tax when sold, reducing the net proceeds. A $100,000 savings account has no tax consequence. A $100,000 traditional IRA is fully taxable upon withdrawal, while a $100,000 Roth IRA is tax-free. In a divorce, comparing face values without considering after-tax values can lead to a settlement that looks equal on paper but is very unequal in practice.

Retirement and QDROs
Retirement and QDROs

Does every retirement account require a QDRO?

No, not every retirement account requires a QDRO. A QDRO (Qualified Domestic Relations Order) is specifically for ERISA-governed employer-sponsored plans like 401(k)s, 403(b)s, and pensions. IRAs are divided by a transfer incident to divorce under the decree itself - no QDRO needed. Federal employee plans (FERS, CSRS, TSP) use a Court Order Acceptable for Processing (COAP). Military retirement follows the Uniformed Services Former Spouses' Protection Act. Utah state plans (URS) have their own requirements. Using the wrong instrument will cause the plan to reject the division.

Retirement and QDROs

What is a QDRO?

A Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) is a court order that allows a retirement plan - typically a 401(k), 403(b), or pension - to divide assets between a plan participant and an alternate payee (usually a spouse or former spouse) as part of a divorce. Without a QDRO, most employer-sponsored retirement plans will not release funds to a non-employee spouse. A properly drafted QDRO avoids early withdrawal penalties and allows the receiving spouse to roll the funds into their own retirement account tax-free.

Investments and Brokerage Accounts
Investments and Brokerage Accounts

How do you trace premarital investments through a commingled brokerage account?

Tracing premarital investments through a commingled brokerage account requires reconstructing the account's transaction history from the date of marriage forward. The analyst identifies the premarital balance, tracks subsequent deposits and withdrawals, and applies tracing methods (such as the pro-rata or lowest-intermediate-balance method) to determine what portion of the current balance is separate property. Without adequate tracing, a commingled account may be presumed entirely marital.

Investments and Brokerage Accounts

How are brokerage and investment accounts divided in a divorce?

Brokerage and investment accounts are divided as marital property to the extent they were funded or grew during the marriage. The accounts are typically valued as of the date of separation or another date set by the court. Non-retirement brokerage accounts can be transferred between spouses or liquidated and split without the tax penalties that apply to retirement accounts. Premarital contributions and separate property growth must be traced and excluded from the marital estate.

Real Estate and Divorce
Real Estate and Divorce

How is home equity divided in a Utah divorce?

In Utah, home equity is divided as part of the equitable distribution of marital property. The court first determines the home's fair market value, subtracts all liens to calculate equity, and identifies any separate property portion. The marital equity is then divided equitably, which means fairly but not necessarily equally. One spouse typically keeps the home through a buyout, or the home is sold and the proceeds are divided after paying the mortgage, closing costs, and any selling expenses.

Real Estate and Divorce

How does a home buyout work in a divorce?

A home buyout in a divorce means one spouse keeps the house and pays the other spouse for their share of the equity. The process involves determining the home's current market value, calculating the equity (value minus mortgage and any other liens), and structuring the payment. The buying spouse typically refinances the mortgage to remove the other spouse's name from the loan and pays the buyout from cash, a cash-out refinance, or by offsetting with other marital assets.

Marital Lifestyle Analysis
Marital Lifestyle Analysis

What is marital standard of living analysis?

Marital standard of living analysis is the process of reconstructing the lifestyle a couple established during their marriage by analyzing their historical spending from bank, credit card, and financial records. In Utah, the standard of living is one of the factors the court considers when determining alimony. The analysis identifies what the couple actually spent - on housing, food, transportation, entertainment, travel, and other categories - to establish a baseline for the support needed to maintain a similar lifestyle after divorce.

Financial Expert Witnesses
Financial Expert Witnesses

When should a divorce attorney hire a financial expert?

A divorce attorney should hire a financial expert when the case involves a closely-held business, self-employment income, separate property claims, complex retirement assets, significant assets with different tax bases, or disputed income. The earlier the expert is engaged - ideally before discovery, settlement discussions, or mediation - the more value they provide. A CDFA®, forensic financial analyst, or valuation professional can identify the financial issues, guide document requests, quantify the marital estate, and provide defensible analysis that strengthens the attorney's position in negotiation or trial.

Financial Expert Witnesses

What is the difference between a CDFA® and a forensic accountant?

A CDFA® (Certified Divorce Financial Analyst) focuses on the financial issues specific to divorce - income analysis, settlement comparisons, after-tax valuations, retirement division, and support calculations. A forensic accountant focuses on investigating financial records to find hidden income, trace separate property, and identify financial irregularities. While there is overlap, a CDFA® is best for the overall financial strategy and settlement analysis, while a forensic accountant is best for investigation and tracing. Many cases benefit from both - and some professionals, like those at Davis Schuler & Associates, hold both CDFA® and forensic credentials.

Financial Expert Witnesses

What does a financial expert witness do in a divorce?

A financial expert witness in a divorce provides analysis, reports, and testimony on financial issues that the court needs to understand. They may value a business, trace separate property, analyze income for support, compare settlement proposals, or investigate hidden assets. The expert prepares a written report, is deposed by the opposing side, and testifies at trial - explaining their methodology, defending their conclusions, and responding to cross-examination. Their role is to provide the court with clear, defensible financial analysis that helps the judge make informed decisions.

Forensic Accounting and Financial Investigation
Forensic Accounting and Financial Investigation

What are the signs of financial dissipation in a divorce?

Financial dissipation occurs when one spouse wastes, spends, or transfers marital assets for purposes unrelated to the marriage, typically in anticipation of divorce. Common signs include large cash withdrawals, excessive spending on a new partner, gambling losses, transfers to friends or family, and unusual business expenses. In Utah, dissipated assets can be added back to the marital estate and credited to the innocent spouse, making it important to identify and document the dissipation.

Forensic Accounting and Financial Investigation

How do you find hidden assets in a divorce?

Finding hidden assets in a divorce involves a systematic financial investigation using bank records, tax returns, business records, and lifestyle analysis. A forensic analyst looks for red flags such as unexplained cash withdrawals, transfers to undisclosed accounts, undervalued business interests, and lifestyle expenses that exceed reported income. The process includes document discovery, tracing funds, and reconstructing the actual financial picture from the paper trail that every transaction leaves behind.

Discuss a Case With Our Financial Expert Team

Talk through the financial issues in your case with a CDFA®, valuation professional, or forensic analyst.

Discuss a case